Local singer/songwriter Alicia Keister's second album, "Heartwood," is a valiant attempt to capture a folksy lyrical sound. With vocals reminiscent of Shawn Colvin, Keister uses guitar-driven melody behind peppy feel-good lyrics.
The album is a good mix of upbeat and slower rhythm with ever-introspective lyrics. Dwelling on spirituality, Keister sometimes falls ito over-used Christian themes (candle in the darkenss imagery, crooked paths, etc.), but overall her strength is in the steady guitar and country sound.
She's at her best the closer she leans toward country on tracks such as "Trouble" and "I Have You," almost starting off like Lee Ann Womack on the latter. When she departs from teh genre, in tracks such as "Open Your Heart," Keister falls just short of a strong folk album and ends up souding like the weak pop that filled the sound of tracks of 1990s TV shows and still plays on soft-rock stations.
The only track that veers from country and still works is "When You Come." It has a slow haunting melody, carried by the piano behind Keister's voice. The instrumentals are simple, but definately the strong point of this song, making it the highlight of the album.
Though "Heartwood" falls just short of its folk endeavors, fans of "Point of Grace" and late '90s contemporary Christian music in general will enjoy this album.
Prasana William - Patriot News, Harrisburg, PA (Aug 30, 2007)
Alicia Keister has a pure and unaffected voice that is nicely complemented by the tasteful and unobrusive arrangements on the 10-song Heartwood. Jason Shaffer of Grantham Road was apparently instrumental (pun intended) in most aspects of bringing Keister's vision to fruition. His mastery of bass (fretless and fretted) and guitar (12-string, slide, electrict, etc.) is the unimposing but fully necessary foundation of this record. Keister's songs are solid, with a confident maturity in their structuring and melody, yet I suspect they would be significantly less interesting if they were stripped of the spot-on production.
Heartwood, while it certainly makes no strides toward anything groundbreaking or inventive, is a solid AAA (adult album alternative) record. This is the kind of album and artist that radio stations like Philadelphia's WXPN were created for. The music is essentially folk with rock and hints of country, especially in the arrangements. The arrangements are so smooth and polished, however, that there are times where the gloss makes the songs a bit less interesting than they could be. Keister's vocal delivery is so smooth and safe with a mild vibrato that she doesn't communicate any intense pathos most of the time. Instead, the songs have a pleasantly sentimental quality that evoke warm sweaters on a windy autumn day. For the most part, the sentimentality comes across as being genuine and not too saccharine, despite the polished production and performance. There are a few exceptions, like "Open Your Heart," which has background vocals that push it just a bit over the edge into easy-listening territory.
There are a few apparent influences instrumentally and vocally. Some of the countrified guitar work reminds me a bit of the clean, crisp playing that one finds on Buddy and Julie Miller records, or the many records that Buddy produces and plays on, including those of Lucinda Williams. Keister is influenced by Patty Griffin, and Beth Amsel and others of that ilk, but she is wise to sing in a straightforward manner that doesn't too overtly reference them. The quality and delivery of her voice, while not altogether unique, is her own. She sings with a subtle confidence that lends an authenticity to the songs even if they could use a ilttle roughing up to make the emotional connection more affecting.
Keister's faith and background in Christian-oriented music is laced throughout Heartwood in a tasteful way that actually feels appropriate with the overall tranquil attitude of the record. In the end, Keister with a boost from Shaffer, has crafted a mature and listenable light folk record in Heartwood.
Dugan Nash - Fly Magazine, Harrisburg, PA (Aug 1, 2007)